Contenuto dell'articolo principale

Abstract

RIASSUNTO

In letteratura il cattivo stato della dentatura nei disabili per ritardo intellettivo è la condizione secondaria che risulta tra le principali cause di limitazione delle attivití  quotidiane quali difficoltí  nell'alimentazione, impedimenti nel parlare, dolore, disturbi del sonno, perdita di capacití  operativa e diminuzione dell'autostima. Lo studio si propone di produrre informazioni sullo stato della dentatura dell'utenza disabile con ritardo intellettivo che afferisce ai Centri Diurni. E' stato adottato un disegno descrittivo di relazioni tra variabili, con campionamento trasversale sistematico costituito da 65 soggetti - disabili mentali - di etí  compresa tra 19 e 44 anni con gruppo caso-controllo reclutato con criterio di convenienza (volontari) costituito da 60 soggetti non disabili, comparabile per variabili personali. La rilevazione dei dati e la misura dello stato di salute sono stati ottenuti con la messa a punto di due strumenti: 1) Griglia di osservazione della dentatura con scala di valutazione delle alterazioni; b) Griglia di uguale contenuto ma con auto-valutazione per gruppo di controllo. I risultati evidenziano una significativa differenza nel numero medio di denti mancanti (9,2) nel campione con disabilití  intellettiva in comparazione con il dato medio (2,3) nel gruppo controllo. Tuttavia, la media di 9.2 denti mancanti del campione locale italiano è migliore del dato internazionale di confronto e cioè 12,3 e 12 rispettivamente per soggetti disabili e controllo (Owens, 2006).

Parole chiave: Ritardo mentale, disabilití  intellettiva, salute dentale, masticazione.

ABSTRACT Impaired dental status in the mentally retarded is one of the principal secondary conditions limiting daily activities such as eating and talking , causing pain, loss of sleep and function and low self-esteem. Little information is available regarding the dental status of the mentally retarded disable attending day centers in Italy. The aim of this study was to provide such information, enrolling 6 day centers in the Veneto region comprising a total number of 65 mentally retarded subjects aged between 19 and 44 years of age. Data were collected using 2 different instuments. Results showed a significantly higher number of teeth missing in the mentally disabled (9.2) in comparison to the control group (2.3) , although this figure is lower than the international one.

Key words: Mental retardation, intellectual disability, oral health, mastication.

Dettagli dell'articolo

Come citare
Bernardi, M. T., & Zanotti, R. (2014). La valutazione della dentatura nei disabili: uno studio caso controllo. PROFESSIONI INFERMIERISTICHE, 63(4). Recuperato da https://www.profinf.net/pro3/index.php/IN/article/view/61

Riferimenti

  • Allison P.J., Hennequin M., (2000, September) The oral assessment in Down syndrome questionnaire (OADS) : development of an instrument to evaluate oral health problems in individuals with Down syndrome. Community Dental Health, 17(3): 172-9.
  • Allison P.J., Lawrence, H.P., (2005, December) Validity of an instrument assessing oral health problems in people with Down syndrome. Community Dental Health, 22(4): 224-30. PMID 16379160
  • Allison P.J., Peyron, M.A., Faye, M., Hennequin, M., (2004, Spring) Video evaluation for mastication validation in persons with Down syndrome. Dysphagia, 19(2): 95-9, PMID: 15382797
  • Altabet, S., Rogers, K., Imes, E., Boatman, I.M., Moncier, J., (2003). Comprehensive approach toward improving oral hygiene at a state residential facility for people with mental retardation. Mental Retardation, 41(6): 440-5.
  • Axelsson, P., Nystrom, B., Linde, J., (2004, September). The long-term effect of plaque control program on tooth mortality, caries and periodontal disease in adults. Results after 30 years of maintenance. Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 31(9): 749-57. PMID 15312097
  • Bernal, C., (2005, Febrary). Maintenance of oral health in people with learning disabilities. Nursing times, 101(6): 40-2. CINHAL AN: 2005056241
  • Chadwick, D.D., Jolliffe, J., Goldbart, J., Burton, M.H., (2006, June). Barriers to caregivers compliance with eating and drinking recommendations for adults with intellectual disabilities and dysphagia. Journal of applied research in Intellectual Disabilities, 19(2): 153-162
  • Chalmers, J., Pearson, A., (2005, Febrary) Oral hygiene care for residents with dementia: a literature review. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 52(4): 410-419
  • Chaushu, S., Yefe Nof, E., Becker, A., Shapira, J., Chaushu, G., (2003, Febrary). Parotid salivary immunoglobulins, recurrent respiratory tract infections and gengival health in institutionalized and non- institutionalized subjects with Down's syndrome. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research; 47(2): 101-7. PMID: 12542575
  • Corbin, S.B., Malina, K., Shepherd, S., (2005). Special Olympics World Summer Games 2003; Healthy Athletes Screening Data Washington, DC: Special Olympics, Inc.
  • Cumella, S., Ransford, N., Lyons, J., Burnham, H., (2000, Febrary). Needs of oral care among people with intellectual disability not in contact with Community Dental Services. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research,44(1): 45-52. PMID 10711649
  • Dogan, M.C., Alacam, A., Asici, N., Odabas, M., Seydaoglu, G., (2004). Clinical evaluation of the plaque-removing ability of three different toothbrushes in a mentally disabled group. Acta Odontologica Scandinavica, 62: 350-354.
  • Donnell, D.O., Sheiham, A., Wai, Y-K., (2002, November-December) Dental findings in 4- 14, and 25- to 35 years-old Hong Kong residents with mental retardation and physical disabilities. Special care in dentistry, 22(6): 231-4. PMID: 12790232
  • Durham, T.M., King, T., Salinas, T., Franco, T., Ross, J., (2006, January- Febrary) Dental Implants in edentulous adults with cognitive disabilities: a report of a pilot project. Special Care in Dentistry, 26(1): 40-6. PMID: 16703934
  • Faulks, D., Hennequin, M., (2000, September- October). Evaluation of a long term oral health program by carers of children and adults with intellectual disabilities. Special Care in Dentistry, 20(5): 199-208. PMID 11203899
  • Feldman, C.A., Giniger, M., Sanders, M., Saporito, R., Zohn, H.K., Perlman, S.P., (2005) Special Olympics, special smiles: assessing the feasibility of epidemiologic data collection. Journal of the American Dental Association, 136(7): 903-912
  • Foster, K.D., Woda, A., Peyron, M.A., (2006, June) Effect of texture of plastic and elastic model foods on the parameters of mastication. Journal of Neurophysiology, 95(6): 3469-79. PMID: 16709719
  • Gabre, P., (2000). Studies on oral health in mentally retarded adults. Swedish Dental Journal Supplement, (142): 1-48. PMID 11204135
  • Gabre, P., Martinsson, T., Gahnberg, L., (1999, Febrary). Incidence of, and reasons for, tooth mortality among mentally retarded adults during a 10-year period. Acta Odontologica Scandinavica, 57(1): 55-61. PMID 10207537
  • Gabre, P., Martinsson, T., Gahnberg, L., (2001, Febrary). Longitudinal study of dental caries, tooth mortality and interproximal bone loss in adults with intellectuall disability. European Journal Of Oral Sciences, 109(1): 20-6. PMID 11330930
  • Gabre, P., Martinsson, T., Gahnberg,. L., (2002). Move of adults with intellectual disability from institutions to community-based living: changes of food arrangements and oral health. Swedish Dental Journal, 26(2): 81-8. PMID 12462876
  • Girimaji, S.C., (2000, May). Commorbidity of mental retardation and affective disorders. Journal of Indian Med Association, 98(5): 245, 248-9. PMID: 11002623
  • Glassman, P., Anderson, M., Jacobsen, P., Schonfeld, S., Weintraub, J., White, A., Gall, T., Hammersmark, S., Isman, R., Miller, C.E., Noel, D., Silverstein, S., Young, D., (2003, a). Practical protocols for the prevention of dental disease in community settings for people with special needs: the protocols. Special Care in Dentistry, 23(5): 160-4 PMID: 14965179
  • Glassman, P., Miller, C., (2003, b). Dental disease prevention and people with special needs. Journal of California Dental Association, 31(2):149-60. PMID: 12636320
  • Glassman, P., Miller, C., Ingraham, R., Woolford, E., (2004, May) The extraordinary vulnerability of people with disabilities: guidelines for oral health professionals. Journal of California Dental Association, 32(5): 379-86. PMID 15253459
  • Gottschalck, T., Dassen, T., Zimmer, S., (2003, October). Assessment scales for nursing assessment of the mouth. A literature review. Pflege, 16(5): 273-82. PMID: 14619219
  • Gravestock, S., (2000, December) Eating disorders in adults with intellectual disability. Journal of Intellectual Disabilities Research, 44(6): 625-37.PMID: 11115017
  • Hennequin, M., Allison, P.J., Faulks, D., Orliaguet, T., Feine, J., (2005, November) Chewing indicators between adults with Down Syndrome and controls. Journal of Dentistry Research, 84(11): 1057-61 PMID: 16246941
  • Hulland, S., Sigal, M.J., (2000, July-Agost) Hospital –based dental care for persons with disabilities: a study of patient selection criteria. Special Care in Dentistry, 20(4): 131-8. PMID 11203888
  • Ishigaki, S., Kurozuni, T., Morishige, E., Yatani, H., (2006, June) Occlusal interference during matication can cause pathological tooth mobility. Journal of Periodontal Research, 41(3): 189-92
  • Jansen, D.E., Krol, B., Groothoff, J.W., Post, D., (2004, Febrary). People with intellectual disability and their problems: a review of comparative studies. Journal of Intellectual Disabilities Research, 48(2): 93-102. PMID 14723652
  • Joynt, (1992). Mental retardation. Clinical Neurology, 55: 28
  • Karjalainen, S., Vanhamaki, M., Kanto, D., Kossi, L., Sewon, L., Salo, M., (2002, Gennaio). Long-term physical inactivity and oral health in Finnish adults with intellectual disability. Acta Odontologica Scandinavica, 60(1): 50-5. PMID 11902613
  • Lange, B., Cook, C., Dunning, D., Froeschle, M.L., Kent, D., (2000, Summer) Improving the oral Hygiene of institutionalized mentally retarded clients. Journal of Dental Hygiene, 74: 205-209. PMID: 11314640
  • Lindemann, R., Zaschel-Grob, D., Opp, S., Lewis, M.A., Lewis,C., (2001) Oral health status of adults from a California regional center for developmental disabilities. Special Care in Dentistry, 21(1): 9-14. PMID 11795453
  • Long, S.K., Coughlin, T.A., Kendall, S.J., (2002, summer) Access to care among disabled adults on Medicaid. Health Care Financ Review, 23(4): 159-73. PMID 12500477
  • Lucchese, C., Checchi, L., (1998, Ottobre). The oral status in mentally retarded institutionalized patients. Minerva Stomatologia, 47(19): 499-502. PMID 9866962
  • Marcenes, W., Steele, J.G., Sheiham, A., Walls, A.W., (2003, June). The relationship between dental status, food selection, nutrient intake, nutritional status, and body mass index in older people. Cad Saude Publica, 19(3): 809-816. PMID: 12806483
  • McGrath, C., Bedi, R., (2001, September) An evaluation of a new measure of oral health related quality of life--OHQoL-UK(W). Community Dental Health, 18(3):138-43. PMID: 11580088
  • McGrath, C., Bedi, R., (2003, Spring) Measuring the impact of oral health on quality of life in Britain using OHQoL- UK(W). Journal of Public Health Dentistry, 63(2): 73-7. PMID: 12816136
  • McGrath, C., Bedi, R., (2004, May) A national study of importance of oral health to life quality to inform scales of oral health related quality of life. Quality Life Research, 13(4): 813-8. PMID15129891
  • Owens, P.L., Kerker, B.D., Zigler, E., Horwitz, S.M., (2006, Genuary). Vision and oral health needs individuals with intellectual disability. Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews, 12(1): 28-40.
  • Pereira, L.J., Duarte Gaviao, M.B., Van Der Bilt, A., (2006, Augost) Influence of oral characteristics and food products on masticatory function. Acta Odontologica Scandinavica, 64(4): 193-201. PMID: 16829493
  • Pezzementi, M.L., Fisher, M.A., (2005, July). Oral health status of people with intellectual disabilities in the southeastern United States. Journal of the American Dental Association, 136(7): 903-12. CINAHL AN: 2009071457.
  • Pilcher, E.S., (2001, November) Treating the patient with Down syndrome. Journal Contemp Dent Pract., 2(4): 58
  • Prater, C.D., Zylstra, R.G., (2006, Giugno). Medical care of adults with mental retardation. American Family Physician, 73(12): 2175-83. PMDI 16836033
  • Read, S., (2005, January) Learning disabilities and palliative care: recognizing pitfalls and exploring potential. Journal of Palliative Nursing, 11(1): 15-20. PMID 15750526
  • Reid B.C., Chenette, R., Macek, M.D., (2003). Prevalence and predictors of untreated caries and oral pain among Special Olympic athletes. Special Care in Dentistry, 23: 129-142
  • Rodriguez Vazquez, C., Garcillon, R., Rioboo, R., Bratos, E., (2002, March). Prevalence of dental caries in an adult population with mental disabilities in Spain. Special Care in Dentistry, 22(2): 65-69. PMID: 12109597
  • Ruddick, L., (2005, November). Health of people with intellectual disabilities: a review of factors influencing access to health care. Journal of Healthy Phychology, 10(4): 559-70. PMID 16238865
  • Rush, K.S., Bowman, L.G., Eidman, S.L., Toole, L.M., Mortenson, B.P., (2004, September). Assessing psychopathology in individuals with developmental disabilities. Behaviour Modification, 28(5): 621-37. PMID: 15296521
  • Sahyoun, N.R., Lin, C.L., Krall, E., (2003, Genuary). Nutritional status of the older adult is associated with dentition status. Journal of American Dietology Association, 103(1): 61-66.
  • Saito, Y., (2006, March) Relationship between occlusal condition and changes of bolus property during mastication. Kokubyo Gakkai Zasshi, 73(1): 107-15 PMID: 16629477
  • Schembri, A., Fiske, J., (2005, September). Oral health and dental care facilities in Maltese residential homes. Gerontology, 22(3): 143-50. PMID: 16163905
  • Shapira, J., Efrat, J., Berkey, D., Mann, J., (1998, Luglio-Agosto). Dental health profile of a population with mental retardation in Israel. Special Care in Dentistry, 18(4): 149-55. PMID 10218062
  • Sheiham, A., Steele, J., (2001). Does the condition of the mouth and teeth affect the ability to eat certain foods, nutrient and dietary intake and nutritional status amongst older people? Public Health Nutrition, 4(3): 797-803.
  • Stanfield, M., Stanfield, M., Scully, C., Davison, M.F., Porter, S., (2003, March) Oral healthcare of clients with learning disability: changes following relocation from hospital to community. Br Dent Journal, 194(5): 271-7 PMID 12658304
  • Tiller, S., Wilson, K.I., Gallagher, J.E., (2001, September). Oral health status and dental service use of adults with learning disabilities living in residential institutions and in the community. Community Dental Health, 18(3): 167-71.PMID: 11580093
  • Traci, M.A., Seekins, T., Szalda- Petree, A., (2002). Assessing secondary conditions among adults with developmental disabilities: A preliminary study. Mental retardation, 40:119-131.
  • Tuffrey-Wijne, I., (2003, Gennaio). The palliative care needs of people with intellectual disabilities: a literature review. Palliative Medicine, 17(1): 55-62
  • Verri, A.P., Maraschio, P., Uggetti, C., Pucci, E., Ronchi, G., Nespoli, L., Destefani, V., Ramponi, A., Federico, A., (2004). Late diagnosis in severe and mild intellectual disability in adulthood. Journal Intellectual Disability Research, 48(7)-. 679-86. PMID: 15357688
  • Waldman, H.B., Perlman, S.P., (2000). Proividing general dentistry for people with disabilities: a demographic review. General Dentistry, 48(5): 566-9; quiz 570-1. PMID: 11199637
  • Waldman, H.B., Perlman, S.P., (2002, a). What about dental care for people with mental retardation? A commentary. Journal of American College of Dentistry, 69(2): 35-38. PMID: 12132257
  • Waldman, H.B., Perlman, S.P., (2002, b). Dental care for individuals with developmental disabilities is expensive, but needed. Journal of California Dental Association, 30(6): 427-32. PMID: 12519052
  • Walls, A.W., Steele, J.G., (2004, December). The relationship between oral health and nutrition in older people. Mech Ageing Development, 125(12): 853-7. PMID: 15563930
  • White, J.A., Beltran, E.D., Malvitz, D.M. et al., (1998). Oral health status of special athletes in the San Francisco Bay area. Journal of Canadian Dentistry Association, 26: 347-353, in Owens, et al., (2006, Genuary). Vision and oral health needs individuals with intellectual disability. Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews, 12(1): 28-40.
  • World Health Organization (2001) International Classification of Functioning Disability and Health. World Health Organization. Geneva. Switzerland.
  • Zigmond,, M., Stabholz, A., Shapira, J., Bachrach, G., Chaushu, G., Becker, A., Yefenof, E., Merrick, J., Chaushu, S., ( 2006, July). The outcome of a preventive dental care programme on the prevalence of localized aggressive periodontitis in Down's Syndrome individuals. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 50(7): 492-500
  • National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS), NHANES III. Periodontitis and three health-enhancing behaviours: maintaining normal weight, engaging in recommended level of exercise and consuming a high-quality diet. Journal of Periodontology.
  • Web site: www.paoleschi.it/paoleschi/denti ; pubblicato 28 agosto 2005
  • Legge Regionale 22/2002: "Autorizzazione e accreditamento delle strutture socio-sanitarie, sanitarie e sociali del Veneto".